Linux in a Windows-centric home network

I was a happy Microsoft employee for many years, and as a result, I run multiple Windows Vista machines at home. My family and I are happy with the system, especially the Vista Media Center / Xbox 360 combination that we use as our Digital Video Recorder, so I'm in no hurry to try and replace my Windows servers with a Linux ones.

This leaves my poor Ubuntu 7.10 Macbook as something of the odd man out. Over the past few weeks I've been learning how to configure it to work with my mostly Windows network.

Wireless Networking

This worked out-of-the-box. If I recall correctly, I had more trouble connecting to my home wireless network when running Apple Macintosh OS X 10.4.

Hah, for what it's worth, my wireless router is a Linksys router that's running Linux, so effectively there's no Windows involved. But I wanted to mention that wireless networking and Internet connectivity worked well out-of-the-box.

Connecting to a Windows Vista File Share

Here's where I ran into my first problem. It turns out that there are multiple ways of connecting to a Windows server in Linux/Ubuntu, and they don't all work reliably. I found that the UI-based way, using the Ubuntu "Places" menu, didn't work for me. I could connect to my windows server, and view the server's directories, but I couldn't reliably read the files. Accessing files was very slow, and reading large files would always time out.

I was able to access my Windows Vista shares by following these instructions:
Mounting Windows Shares in Ubuntu <-- allowed me to read my Window shares.
Permission issues with smb and cifs <-- allowed me to delete files on my shares.

The downside of the command-line approach is that you don't get a nice icon on your desktop, you have to navigate to /mnt/myshare/... yourself. But it's reliable. You can partially work around this by creating a symbolic link from your desktop to your share. The reason this is a partial work-around is that Nautilus will think that the resulting directory is a "local" directory, so it will try to do i/o intensive things like create preview icons. Oh well.

For what it's worth, the reliability problem with the default way of accessing Windows shares seems to be due to Ubuntu using the older, out-of-date smbfs system instead of the more modern cifs system. You'd think a hip, happening OS like Ubuntu would fix this problem, but it's a long-standing one, so I guess it hasn't made it to the top of their priority list yet.

Windows Printing

This was easy.
  1. First I shared out my printer on my Windows Vista machine. (I never bothered to do that before.)
  2. Then on my Ubuntu machine I choose the System:Administration:Printing menu item.
  3. Clicked on the New Printer icon
  4. Chose "Windows Printer via SAMBA".
  5. Fill in the dialog box. Use the handy "verify" button to verify that you've done it right.
  6. Click on Forward and finish the configuration.
I was pleased to find my printer's model number mentioned in the driver list. Everything worked the first time.


admix said…
I can recommend you a smb4k. Nice gui for mounting/unmounting of SMB shares. It depends on KDE, but worth it.
Jack Palevich said…
Alas, smb4k doesn't work well for my home network. The problem is that I am using a wireless network. Both smb4k and Ubuntu's built-in nautilus browser use "smb:" URIs to play movies off of SMB shares. "smb:" shares just timeout too frequently on a wireless network to be useful.

In contrast, using a cifs mount works fine -- the video pauses occasionally, but then starts again .

One downside of a cifs mount is that my laptop hangs for 40 seconds or so when shutting down, because it wants to cleanly shut down the cifs mount _after_ the wireless network is already disconnected.

But for me I'm happier to have working video than a quick shutdown.

Popular posts from this blog

GLES Quake - a port of Quake to the Android platform

A Taipei-Torrent postmortem: Writing a BitTorrent client in Go

Using a Mac keyboard with Ubuntu Linux